Anna Maria Island Cafe Menu: Where To Eat And What To Order (2024)

When visiting the beautiful Anna Maria Island, there is no shortage of delicious dining options. From fresh seafood to gourmet burgers, this charming island has something for every palate. In this menu guide, we will highlight some must-try restaurants and dishes on the island. Whether you are looking for a casual beachfront spot or a romantic dinner with ocean views, our guide will help you navigate the diverse culinary scene on Anna Maria Island.

Introduction to Anna Maria Island and its Unique Dining Scene

Anna Maria Island Cafe Menu: Where To Eat And What To Order (1)

Anna Maria Island is a hidden gem on the west coast of Florida, known for its stunning beaches and laid-back island vibe. This barrier island offers visitors a true escape from the hustle and bustle of city life, with quaint shops, charming streets, and delicious food.

One of the highlights of visiting Anna Maria Island is trying out the diverse dining scene. Despite being only 7 miles long, the island is home to a wide range of restaurants, from casual beachfront eateries to upscale fine dining establishments. Many of these restaurants offer outdoor seating with beautiful ocean views, making for a truly memorable dining experience.

What sets Anna Maria Island’s dining scene apart is its focus on fresh and locally sourced ingredients. With so many nearby farms and fisheries, the island’s restaurants take advantage of the abundance of fresh produce and seafood to create flavorful and unique dishes.

Visitors can also find international cuisine on Anna Maria Island. From Italian classics to Thai favorites, there is no shortage of options for those looking to expand their palates.

The Waterfront Restaurant: A Must-Try Dining Experience on Anna Maria Island

Located on the northern end of Anna Maria Island, The Waterfront Restaurant offers a dining experience that is both elegant and relaxed. With indoor and outdoor seating options, diners can choose to admire the stunning views of Tampa Bay from the waterfront patio or enjoy a cozy meal inside the charming dining room.

The menu at The Waterfront features a variety of dishes incorporating local seafood, meats, and produce. Some must-try items include the Lobster Mac & Cheese, made with Gulf shrimp, Maine lobster, and a blend of cheeses, and the Blackened Grouper Sandwich, served on a brioche bun with mango salsa and Cajun remoulade.

Often referred to as the best kept secret on Anna Maria Island, The Waterfront also offers an extensive wine list and handcrafted co*cktails. Be sure to save room for dessert and try one of their decadent options, such as the Warm Chocolate Lava Cake or the Key Lime Pie.

History and Background of the Waterfront Restaurant

The Waterfront Restaurant is a renowned establishment that has been serving delectable dishes and quality drinks since its inception. Located in the heart of Anna Maria Island, Florida, the restaurant boasts a rich history and background that has contributed to its success over the years.

As a popular destination for locals and tourists alike, the Waterfront Restaurant has become synonymous with excellent dining experiences and exceptional service.

The Waterfront Restaurant menu offers a diverse selection of dishes, ranging from seafood and steak to vegetarian options, ensuring that there is something for everyone to enjoy. Along with a wide array of delicious meals, the restaurant also has an impressive drink menu, featuring an extensive wine list and carefully chosen craft beers.

But what makes the Waterfront Restaurant truly special is its charming location overlooking the Anna Maria City Pier and Tampa Bay. The picturesque views and relaxed atmosphere make it an ideal spot for a romantic dinner, family gathering, or casual lunch with friends.

The history of the restaurant dates back to 1992 with passion and vision for creating a unique dining experience. Now, almost three decades later, the Waterfront Restaurant continues to be a celebrated dining destination in Anna Maria Island.

Throughout the years, the restaurant has undergone several renovations and improvements to keep up with evolving trends and tastes. However, its commitment to providing exceptional food and service has remained constant.

Unique Atmosphere and Ambiance of the Restaurant

The Waterfront Restaurant not only offers delicious food and drinks, but it also boasts a unique atmosphere and ambiance that sets it apart from other dining establishments on Anna Maria Island. From the moment you step inside, you are greeted with warm and friendly service, creating a welcoming and inviting atmosphere.

The restaurant features both indoor and outdoor seating options, each with its own charm. The outdoor patio is the perfect spot to enjoy a meal while taking in the stunning views of Tampa Bay and the Anna Maria City Pier. The indoor dining room offers a cozy and intimate setting with its rustic decor and beautiful artwork.

The restaurant’s ambiance is further enhanced by live music, which can be enjoyed on select nights throughout the week. From jazz to acoustic sets, these performances add an extra layer of ambiance to an already charming dining experience.

Signature Dishes and Must-Try Items at the Waterfront Restaurant

Looking for a memorable dining experience? Look no further than the Waterfront Restaurant! Our menu features a variety of delicious dishes, each crafted with care by our talented chefs. Here are some signature dishes and must-try items that you simply have to try when visiting us.

  • d’Esclans Whispering Angel | 2020 (Provence) – a light and refreshing Provencal rose that pairs perfectly with our seafood dishes.
  • Suzor “The Tower” 2018 (Oregon) – a bold red blend featuring notes of black fruit and spices, perfect for pairing with our steak or lamb dishes.
  • Anna Bella Cabernet Sauvignon | 2020 (Napa) – a smooth and fruity Napa Cabernet that pairs perfectly with our red meat dishes.
  • Mollydooker’s “The Scooter” Merlot | 2019 (Mclaren Vale, Australia) – a rich and flavorful Australian Merlot that pairs perfectly with our hearty dishes like beef stroganoff or lamb chops.
  • Ghost Block Zinfandel | 2021 (Napa) – a rich and full-bodied Zinfandel with notes of dark fruit, perfect for pairing with our BBQ ribs or burgers.
  • Catena Malbec | 2019 (Mendoza, Argentina) – a bold and velvety Malbec that pairs perfectly with our grilled meats or hearty pastas.
  • Chappellet Mountain Cuvee | 2021 (Napa & Sonoma) – a well-balanced red blend featuring notes of dark fruit and oak, perfect for pairing with our signature dishes like the Waterfront Steak or Seafood Platter.

Extensive Wine List and Craft Beer Selections for Guests to Enjoy

Our restaurant offers an extensive wine list and craft beer selection for our guests to enjoy. From well-known varietals to unique blends, we have a wide range of wines from different regions around the world. Our draft and bottled beer menu includes both domestic favorites and handpicked craft beers for those looking to try something new.

Wine Selections:

We have carefully selected a variety of red and white wines to complement our menu. Our selection includes:

  • Pinot Noir: A light-bodied red wine with notes of tart fruit and a dry finish, perfect for pairing with seafood or poultry.
  • Argyle Estate | 2022 | Willamette Valley-Oregon
  • Michael Pozzan | 2020 | Russian River Valley-California
  • Chardonnay: A full-bodied white wine with buttery and oaky notes, pairs well with creamy dishes or rich seafood.
  • Rombauer | 2021 | Carneros-Napa
  • Kendall Jackson Vintners Reserve | 2020 | California
  • Sauvignon Blanc: A light and crisp white wine with notes of citrus and herbs, great for pairing with salads or seafood.
  • Kim Crawford | 2021 | Marlborough New Zealand
  • Matua Valley | 2020 | Marlborough New Zealand

Red Wines:

Our red wine selection features a variety of bold and complex flavors, including:

  • Cabernet Sauvignon: A full-bodied, tannic wine with dark fruit notes and a long finish. Perfect for pairing with red meat dishes.
  • Alexander Valley Vineyards | 2019 (Sonoma County)
  • Segla | 2015 (Margaux)
  • Merlot: A medium-bodied wine with soft tannins and fruity flavors, great for pairing with pasta or poultry dishes.
  • Markham | 2018 | Napa
  • Mollydooker’s “The Scooter” | 2019 | Mclaren Vale-Australia
  • Zinfandel: A bold and fruity wine with low tannins, pairs well with BBQ dishes or red meats.
  • Ghost Block | 2021 | Napa
  • Ridge | 2018 (Paso-Robles, California)

Seasonal Menu Changes and Special Events at the Cafe

At the Waterfront Restaurant, we believe in constantly evolving and keeping things fresh. That’s why we have seasonal menu changes to showcase the best and freshest ingredients each season has to offer. Our chefs work closely with local farmers and suppliers to source high-quality, locally-sourced ingredients for our dishes.

We also love to mix things up and host special events at our cafe. From wine pairing dinners to holiday-themed menus, we always have something exciting planned for our guests. These events not only give us a chance to showcase new and unique dishes but also create a fun and lively atmosphere for our patrons.

Anna Maria Island is famous for its beautiful beaches and laid-back atmosphere, but at the Waterfront Restaurant, we strive to offer a dining experience that is just as memorable.

Why the Waterfront Restaurant on Anna Maria Island Should be Your Next Dining Destination?

People choose to dine at a restaurant for various reasons, whether it’s for a special occasion, date night, or just a craving for delicious food. But when it comes to choosing the perfect dining destination, there are certain things that set one restaurant apart from the others. At the Waterfront Restaurant on Anna Maria Island, we believe in creating an unforgettable experience for our guests through our

The restaurant’s location is hard to beat. With stunning views of Tampa Bay and the Anna Maria City Pier, diners can enjoy their meal while taking in the beautiful scenery. The outdoor patio also provides a perfect spot for al fresco dining and watching the sunset.

The menu at the Waterfront Restaurant is carefully curated to showcase the best local ingredients and flavors. From fresh seafood to perfectly cooked steaks, every dish is crafted with care and attention to detail. And with a variety of options for wine and craft beer lovers, there is something for everyone to enjoy.

Anna Maria Island Cafe Menu: Where To Eat And What To Order (2024)


What is the southern tip of Anna Maria Island? ›

The most Southern tip of Anna Maria Island is known as Coquina beach and has parking for hundreds of vehicles with a sidewalk path just to the East of the beach that makes bicycling or walking 10+ blocks North and South away from the hustle and bustle of Gulf Drive.

How do you spend a day at Anna Maria Island? ›

  1. Clear Kayak Glass Bottom Day Tour - Anna Maria Island. ...
  2. The Island Tour. ...
  3. Amazing Anna Maria Island Scavenger Hunt. ...
  4. Half Day Private Fishing Trip with Site Seeing Around Anna Maria Island. ...
  5. Parasailing Adventure in Anna Maria Island. ...
  6. Half Day Private Luxury Boat Charter.

What time does Anna Maria open? ›

The park is open from sunrise to 10 p.m. and is a wonderful spot to try out any time of the day. There are three access points to the beach which makes it easy to get to and enjoy.

Can you walk Anna Maria Island? ›

Anna Maria Island is a hidden gem that makes the ideal location for a getaway with your family or your sweetheart. At just 7 miles long, this tiny island is easy to get around, so you can simply walk or bike between your rental and your destination.

What celebrities are at Anna Maria Island? ›

In the two decades since, AMI has slowly but steadily lost its “best-kept secret” status, drawing increasing numbers of tourists from around the country and globe, including occasional celebrity visitors (Tim McGraw, Faith Hill, Cameron Diaz and Jared Leto are among the stars seen on the island).

Can you drink the tap water in Anna Maria Island? ›

Typically, the island depends on wells that extract water from the Floridan Aquifer. This extensive underground limestone formation underlies a significant portion of Florida and stands as a primary drinking water source for the state. The Floridan Aquifer's distinction lies in its water of high quality.

Is the trolley on Anna Maria Island free? ›

Anna Maria Island has a free Trolley Service that travels daily up and down the island between Anna Maria Island and Coquina Beach, from 6AM- 10:30PM, about every 20 minutes. It is a cool ride on a hot day. About every 2-4 blocks there is a Trolley Stop, most have covered seating while you wait.

Is Anna Maria Island expensive? ›

With lodging costing an average $294 per night for its most affordable double room, Anna Maria Island was Florida's most expensive spring destination and fifth overall in the United States, according to a survey by

What month is best to go to Anna Maria Island? ›

The best time to visit Anna Maria Island is all year round depending on why you are visiting. Our tourism score for weather is very high January, February, March, April, October, November and December. May and September are shoulder tourism scores with June, July and August half of May and September.

How late does the trolley run on Anna Maria Island? ›

Trolleys typically run at 20 minute intervals until 9pm, then every 30 minutes until 10:30pm. (times may vary due to unforeseen incidents, traffic conditions or weather) You'll never be far from a trolley stop, you can usually find them every two to four blocks.

Does Anna Maria Beach have a boardwalk? ›

The pier is a popular spot for anglers who fish for Redfish, Snook, Spanish Mackerel, Pompano, Sharks, and more. You'll typically find locals and visitors strolling the boardwalk taking in the sights of this authentic Anna Maria landmark.

Is there a curfew on Anna Maria Island? ›

Curfew at all parks within the city is midnight. It is unlawful to disturb any turtle nests on the beaches.

What is the least crowded beach on Anna Maria Island? ›

For the quiet getaway

For that there is the hidden gem of Bean Point – a beautiful white sand beach found at the very tip of Anna Maria Island. Once you find its “secret” entrance you'll know you're in for a treat. This beach is always quiet, secluded and sparsely populated.

Is it safe to swim in Anna Maria Island? ›

Be cautious at all times. Never swim alone. Whenever possible, swim at a lifeguard-protected beach. On Anna Maria Island, there are two public beaches—Coquina Beach and Manatee County Public Beach—that have lifeguards present between 9:00 a.m. and 5:00 p.m.

Is Anna Maria Island crowded? ›

AMI Spring Break

Spring break typically happens in March, leaving the months of April and May somewhat less crowded (and a bit more quiet). The island comes alive during this time, with pops of color from blooming flowers, the stir of wildlife, and the energy that the crowds bring.

Which town is at the southernmost tip? ›

Kanyakumari is at the southern tip and is the southernmost point of the contiguous Indian Subcontinent.

What are the boundaries of Anna Maria Island? ›

It is bounded on the west by the Gulf of Mexico, on the south by Longboat Pass (which separates it from Longboat Key), on the east by Anna Maria Sound, and on the north by Tampa Bay.

What are the three towns on Anna Maria Island? ›

There are three towns on AMI: Anna Maria in the north, Holmes Beach in the center, and Bradenton Beach on the south side. You can take Gulf Drive from one end to the other in about 25 minutes by golf cart.


Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Rob Wisoky

Last Updated:

Views: 6700

Rating: 4.8 / 5 (48 voted)

Reviews: 87% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Rob Wisoky

Birthday: 1994-09-30

Address: 5789 Michel Vista, West Domenic, OR 80464-9452

Phone: +97313824072371

Job: Education Orchestrator

Hobby: Lockpicking, Crocheting, Baton twirling, Video gaming, Jogging, Whittling, Model building

Introduction: My name is Rob Wisoky, I am a smiling, helpful, encouraging, zealous, energetic, faithful, fantastic person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.